Purchase this article with an account.
Zili Liu, Hongjing Lu, Ning Qian; Learning motion discrimination without MT. Journal of Vision 2001;1(3):27. doi: 10.1167/1.3.27.
Download citation file:
© ARVO (1962-2015); The Authors (2016-present)
Purpose: to study visual perceptual learning of motion discrimination using paired dot stimuli that are known to suppress MT activity. Method: In a 2AFC task, two random-dot motion stimuli were presented sequentially, each for 200 ms, with an ISI of 500 ms. Each stimulus consisted of 100 pairs of random dots within a circular aperture, and each pair oscillated in opposite directions across each other with an amplitude of 0.3 degrees of visual angle and a life time of 120 ms. The stimuli were thereby locally balanced everywhere, and hence strongly suppressed MT activity (Qian, Anderson, and Adelson, 1994). In each trial, the motion-axes of the two stimuli differed by 8 degrees. The subject judged if the change of motion-axis from the first to the second stimulus was clockwise or counter-clockwise. No static frames of the stimuli provided any information about the motion-axis. This was achieved by positioning one dot pair next to another pair of the same motion-axis so that the four dots formed a parallelogram. The two pairs were positioned so close to each other that the shortest separation was often between dots in different pairs. Therefore, the proximity-based salient orientation defined by two closest dots was often random rather than along the motion-axis. Consequently, the motion-axis of each stimulus was defined by motion alone. 20% of the dot pairs were noise, oscillating along randomly chosen axes. Results: Substantial learning (d′=1.38 to d′=2.69) was obtained. However, when the task was more difficult (5 degrees of angular difference between the motion-axes), learning was impossible even though the performance was well above chance (d′=1.26, 15 sessions, 400 trials each). This result from 1 subject was replicated by 4 additional subjects. Conclusion: MT may not be critical for learning motion discrimination, but task difficulty is critical.
This PDF is available to Subscribers Only