Purchase this article with an account.
Russell Adams, Michele Mercer, Jagger Mercer/Adams; Consistency of Individual Measurements Between Different Sensory Modalities: Vision vs. Audition and the Haptic Senses. Journal of Vision 2018;18(10):98. doi: 10.1167/18.10.98.
Download citation file:
© ARVO (1962-2015); The Authors (2016-present)
Purpose. In recent work (VSS 2013, 2015), we have made comparisons among the human senses, focusing primarily on common patterns within general threshold responding. Results show that vision (notably contrast sensitivity) shares some commonalities with audition and surprisingly, and also with some aspects within the sense of pain. Another question, particularly for clinicians, is which of these modalities yields the most consistent results across assessments. To address this question, we conducted an intensive assessment of adults tested repeatedly with primarily psychophysical measures of vision, hearing, touch and pain. Method. 15 young adults were tested repeatedly (M = 8 repetitions) with the most widely used clinical measures of spatial vision [log MAR optotype acuity, contrast sensitivity (FACT, Vector Vision, Rabin tests), and refractive error (autorefraction)], audition (complete audiology exam), touch (Von Frey fibres on the ventral and dorsal aspects of the hand), and pain (fingertip pressure algometry). Results. To make measures comparable, data across all tests and modalities were standardized to individual logarithmic scales. Coefficient of reliability analyses showed that except for autorefraction, all measures of vision showed the most consistency, followed by measures of touch, audition, and pain. Conclusions. Our data indicate that, except for optical measurements (likely due to varying accommodation), repeated assessments of vision (often weeks apart) are highly stable, and are superior in this regard to the other sensory modalities. Although this may be due in part to the precision and scaling of the existing psychophysical techniques for measuring vision, it also may be due to the fact that threshold decision making within visual tasks requires the highest degree of cortical integration among all sensory modalities.
Meeting abstract presented at VSS 2018
This PDF is available to Subscribers Only